After being mugged,
Miss Prim decides to leave New York City and purchase a home in the country, where she will be safe from dangerous criminals.
A devoted reader of crime fiction, Miss Prim believes that her reading of detective novels has given her all the skills she
needs to become an amateur sleuth in her new home base of Greenfield, Connecticut. Miss Prim gets the chance to prove her
mettle when she finds a corpse in her basement. As she investigates (with her trusty Boxer, Bruno, at her side), Miss Prim
begins to suspect that someone in Greenfield is watching her every move, waiting for the right moment to strike. Will Miss
Prim, with her insights into human behavior and her steadfast refusal to rely on forensic techniques (which she considers
the crutches of lazy investigators), be able to choose between two devoted suitors, save herself, and bring everything to
a satisfactory resolution?
“Mystery has energy. It pours energy into whoever seeks the answer to it.”
Fowles, The Magus
A House in the Country
When, after many years of living quite peacefully in New York City, Miss Felicity Prim
felt herself being mugged for the first time, her initial thought was: My handbag is caught on something. As she
lay in the hospital, watching Doctor Poe set her fractured arm, she wondered: Why did the mugger choose me?
Then she vowed: This will never happen again.
she had to recover before taking action. The doctor had prescribed an intense regimen of relaxation and inactivity (a challenging
requirement for an active New Yorker). She was to remain at home for a month, in her bright, rent-controlled, one-bedroom
apartment on East 26th Street, and focus on getting better. Her sister, friends, and coworkers would run her errands, pick
up her dry cleaning, and bring her whatever she needed or wanted: meals, groceries, magazines.
And what she wanted most, she found, were the books she’d scoped out during her last visit to the Union Square
Barnes & Noble. She’d scribbled the titles on the notepad she kept in her handbag—the same handbag that had
contained her wallet, which the mugger had probably tossed in a trashcan after removing the cash from it. Fortunately, she
didn’t need the notepad to remember the books she’d planned to purchase. She’d been awaiting payday, turning
the titles over in her head, thinking about the hints they provided regarding plot and character. Miss Prim rattled off the
list to Dolly, who returned several hours later, apologizing that she’d lost track of time. As if such apologies were
necessary! Because that is what one does in a bookstore: One loses track of time.
With one arm in a sling and a book in her hand, Miss Prim looked out of the window of her front room. Ten stories beneath
her, city workers were situating the latest art installation in Madison Square Park. A man wearing a cowboy hat (the artist?)
waved frantically at the installers. As Miss Prim settled into her easy chair near the window, she thought: Perhaps getting
mugged was a blessing in disguise. At last, I have time to read as much as I want to. Over the next month, I shall
read without being jostled, poked, and prodded on buses and subway cars. I shall read what I like, when
I like, and not just for an hour before I go to sleep, or at my desk while I hurry through lunch.
How she admired the protagonists of her books, those worthy men and women of crime fiction! They did not work
in a doctor’s office ten hours a day, five or six days a week. They did not get mugged while walking along
city streets and minding their own business. They took charge of their lives. When they encountered a mysterious
situation, they took matters into their own hands. Uncooperative politicians, corrupt corporate raiders, overworked policemen,
those who insisted that everything was perfectly lovely despite the heroine’s fears: None of these stood in the sleuth’s
way. In the end, justice was served and the universe was restored to balance. Why? Because, by the end of the novel, the sleuth
had used her superior intelligence—not common violence—to outsmart the criminal.
A month passed and the sling was removed from her arm. The evening before she was due to return to Doctor Poe’s
office, she reminded herself of her vow—This will never happen again—and studied herself in the mirror.
She needed to get in shape. Once an athletic young woman who could hold her own in a badminton tournament, she had
allowed a certain thickness to set in around the waist and ankles. She’d become lax about walking when cabs were plentiful,
and she’d begun indulging in her favorite New York caloriefest, the black-and-white cookie, rather too often. The confection
was, she was forced to admit, nothing more than a sugar-slathered, fat- and cholesterol-laden cake masquerading as something
less insidious. She marched into her kitchen, located the cookies Celia had given her a day earlier, and pitched them into
the garbage pail.
The next day she took her usual
route to Doctor Poe’s office, looking over her shoulder often; much more frequently, in fact, than she’d done
in the 1970s, when New York City was much more dangerous, or in the stressful days after 9/11. In the past, she’d enjoyed
watching people, wondering about the lives and loves of those she passed on the streets. Now she found herself wondering why
this one looked so suspicious, that one appeared dangerous, and the other one seemed to be up to
That night, after her joyous return
to Doctor Poe’s office—for everyone in acknowledged that they simply could not have gone on any longer without
her—Miss Prim stopped at Chelsea Piers, a co-ed gym on the Hudson River. The time had come to join a health club, and
her goal was to find one in an inconvenient location. Walking to and from a somewhat distant health club, she reasoned, would
provide more of a workout than taking a cab to a local one.
receiving a tour of the facility she nearly fled in embarrassment, almost believing she’d stumbled into a Victoria’s
Secret or Playboy “Women of Manhattan” photo shoot, what with all the well-coiffed, perfectly lipsticked
and mascara’ed young women so provocatively dressed in skintight Spandex leggings and sausage-casing bras. Yes, these
are the models, Miss Prim thought; and the young men with the large biceps in tank tops and skinny legs in cargo shorts were
the photographers or tech crew. But no, all of the males appeared to be working out on intricate machinery or with various
weight bars, stopping every few minutes to admire themselves in the mirrors. At Doctor Poe’s office she’d become
aware of the narcissism of the younger generation, that hyperconnected yet disaffected cohort attempting to find its way in
the big city. But until she stepped foot into Chelsea Piers she hadn’t realized quite how out of control things had
She signed a contract for a shockingly
expensive three-month trial membership.
a women’s center in Greenwich Village, she enrolled in a self-defense course taught by a tough-looking man named Sal
who, Miss Prim discovered during the fourth class, was actually a woman. She learned how to perform an arm twist to extricate
herself from an unwanted grip, as well as effective methods to prevent herself from being strangled.
Still, it is one thing to take on a trained instructor within the confines of a controlled classroom, quite another
to confront a crack or meth addict. (Yes, Miss Prim knew about these substances. One does not work in a doctor’s office
for decades without learning about life on the streets.) In certain situations—those in which charm and intelligence
do not succeed in disarming attackers, and those in which one is outnumbered—more drastic measures might be necessary.
Miss Prim drew a nonnegotiable line at firearms, however. She’d been raised to believe that violence creates
more problems than it solves, and as she’d matured she had found her own belief system mirrored by that particular piece
A taser, Miss Prim decided,
was the answer. She asked Dolly to purchase one for her, as Dolly was quite facile with using computers to purchase hard-to-find
items. Dolly, still shaken by Miss Prim’s recent misfortune, agreed, and a week later she handed her friend the latest
in electrical self-protection technology, the Laser Taser 3000. Miss Prim took ownership of the device while vowing never
to use it. Unless absolutely necessary.
weeks after taking possession of the Laser Taser 3000, Miss Prim arrived at her apartment building on East 26th Street and
headed for the staircase, which was tucked into a remote corner of the lobby. Taking a deep breath, she began walking up the
ten flights of stairs. This was part of her new physical fitness regimen. Walking up the stairs, she’d read, is much,
much better for the waistline than standing in an elevator.
reached the third floor when she thought she heard a staircase door open behind her. And then … the sounds of someone
climbing the staircase aggressively, perhaps two stairs at a time.
Miss Prim picked up her pace. It was fanciful to think someone was chasing her up the staircase. Wasn’t it?
As she began running up the stairs, she heard the person behind her approaching rapidly. She wasn’t going to
make it to the tenth floor. He—it must be a he, mustn’t it?—was younger, faster, breathing heavily.
She felt a hand touch her shoulder.
What did she do, after
taking that course to boost her self-defense abilities and her confidence? She kneeled in a corner of the landing and screamed.
“Miss Prim, are you OK?” The voice belonged to George, the sweet-natured, slightly overweight doorman who’d
worked in her building for more than twenty years. He extended his hand and helped Miss Prim to her feet.
“Miss Prim, I’m real sorry, I didn’t mean to scare you. Your sister stopped by today and left this
package for you.” He held out a small box. “I was putting the broom away in the closet when I saw you go into
the stairway. I thought I could catch you before you got up to your apartment.”
After Miss Prim returned to her apartment, locked the door’s three bolts, and placed the safety bar under the
doorknob, she sat at her kitchen table and unwrapped Celia’s package: low-gluten, low-carb, low-fat, low-cholesterol
minicakes from a trendy bakery that had just opened in Celia’s West Village neighborhood.
Miss Prim caught a glimpse of herself in the reflective foil in which the minicakes had been wrapped. She didn’t
recognize the person looking back at her. A haggard, fearful mess had replaced an upbeat, positive, independent woman.
And she knew, as deeply as she’d ever known anything, that it was time to leave New York City. To retire. To
find a little house in the country where she’d be safe.
As Miss Prim planned the next stage of her life, wondered: What would Papa (which she pronounced by accenting the second
syllable) have recommended? What would Mama (which she also pronounced by accenting the second syllable) have advised?
Papa would have asked, Do you think, perhaps, that after so many years of living in Manhattan, you are longing
for the summers we spent on Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard? You often spoke about how much you loved the house we rented,
how free you felt having your own four walls, a yard, and a garden. A house in the country is a wonderful thing; and if you
want one, you should have one.
Mama would have said, Felicity,
this is the twenty-first century. You are free to make your own decisions. There will be risks involved in decamping to the
country, yes; but I hope I have taught you to see life’s challenges as opportunities for growth and higher levels of
wisdom. You have always helped other people; perhaps it is time you did something for yourself. And I know you, dearest; no
matter where you go, you will find a way to help people, just as you do now, every day, in Doctor Poe’s office.
Miss Prim smiled as she straightened up the front room of her apartment, reorganizing a bookshelf on which, somehow,
the books had gotten out of alphabetical order. The question was, of course, how to take combine parents’ sage advice
into a cohesive whole. “A house in the country” plus “helping people” equals … what exactly?
Certainly the book in her hand—the latest in the long-running series featuring plucky female sleuth Fatima Larroquette,
New Orleans native and devoted Wiccan—wouldn’t help her make any decisions.
Or would it? Heroes and heroines are found everywhere, not just in big cities, Miss Prim reflected. To be helpful to
one’s fellow man, one need not save the world from greedy corporations and devious terrorist cells. One could be of
service while serving as a criminal outsmarter in a New England village, helping the locals find stolen jewelry, solving missing-persons
cases, and uncovering malfeasance in Town Hall. Certainly if Fatima Larroquette, heroine of When Life Hands You Limes,
Make Limeade, could do it, so could Miss Felicity Prim.
Once Miss Prim decided to undertake a career in criminal outsmarting, she found that such a drastic change in lifestyle
could not be accomplished without a good deal of preparation.
there was the need for additional, specialized education. Yes, she had her degree from Teachers’ College, granted so
many years ago, and she treasured the liberal arts with all her being. She was not so naïve as to believe, however, that
a more-than-passing acquaintance with Spinoza, Chaucer, and Locke would stand her in good stead when engaging with criminal
types. No, she would need schooling in certain legal and procedural matters, thus acquainting herself with the limits of what
she could do (legally, as a concerned citizen) without falling afoul of the authorities.
As for forensics, ballistics, and those other aspects of modern crime-scene investigation—she dismissed them
with a mental wave of her hands. These were, she believed, crutches used by people with little or no imagination, moderate
(at best) intelligence, and a tendency to prefer cold, hard facts over the psychological factors involved in crime. How thoroughly
weary she’d become of CSI: Something or Other, which seemed to proselytize the message that blood spatter,
microfibers, and stray hairs could answer all questions. No. As Miss Prim knew from decades of counseling patients at Doctor
Poe’s office, at the heart of all problems lie relationships and people, not strands of DNA.
At the New School, where Miss Prim had signed up for the accelerated course in criminal justice, Miss Prim met with
her advisor to discuss the choices available to fledgling criminal outsmarters. Interestingly, Miss Prim noted, these options
more or less corresponded to those followed by the fictional protagonists in the books she adored.
Policewoman? her advisor suggested. No, police work would not do, Miss Prim replied. She was not one to gladly
take orders from fools above her in the police hierarchy. She knew from reading Ed McBain and Dell Shannon how much time she’d
spend knocking on doors and filling out useless paperwork, and she did not want to waste her time (or her talents) cutting
through red tape and fending off the advances of oversexed coworkers. For, in fiction at least, there seemed to be at least
one roué in every police squad, and who had time for that?
Private detective? If she’d decided to continue living in New York, perhaps. In such a complicated city,
she’d have no difficulty getting work, helping worthy clients find swindlers and cheating spouses. But private detection
could too easily lead her into a hardboiled world. And she did not relish the idea of searching through Mafia safe houses
for stashes of stolen money or befriending transgendered prostitutes with cruel and merciless pimps who would not have thought
twice about bashing Miss Prim’s delicate skull. The Underworld might be an interesting place to visit in fiction every
now and again, but she did not wish to take up permanent residence there.
Profiler? Certainly a high-interest job, and one to which she felt suited, for don’t the most depraved
criminals have the most interesting psychology (usually as a result of the poor parenting they received)? To be a profiler,
though, she’d probably have to work for the FBI or the CIA. On the positive side, she could live somewhere in the country
and report into Quantico or Langley when her services were needed. But, she told her advisor, she didn’t want to get
involved in the federal bureaucracy, what with all the infighting, incompetence, double agents, and so on.
Forensics? Absolutely not, for the aforementioned reasons.
In the end, she was left with the choice that she’d always known, in her heart, would be right for her: a cozy
criminal outsmarter, living in a lovely cottage with a garden, in a town where nothing truly bad happens. And she knew where
she might find such a place: in Connecticut.